After the demolition: A trader stares helplessly at his demolished stall
Emotions ran high few days ago in Makurdi the Benue State capital when
the state government rolled out its bulldozers against traders at the
multi-million Naira, Makurdi Modern Market.
Market stalls which traders claimed millions of Naira was expended to
erect on the approval of the state were pulled down at the instance of
the government. At the end of the first phase of the exercise no fewer
than 40 stalls had been pulled down with goods valued at over N150
million destroyed in the process.
The action of the government sparked off angry reaction from the
traders who in protest shut down the market, while spoiling for more
showdown with the authorities. This development is already creating
serious strain on the socio-economic life of the state.
The traders contended that the demolition of their stalls and
destruction of their goods was in total negation of an earlier agreement
they entered with the state government, years before the advent of the
present administration.
Narrating their ordeal to newsmen in Makurdi, an amalgamated union of
the traders through their chairman, Mr. Patrick Ajie, the traders
lamented the action of the state government, adding that since the
advent of the second tenure of the present administration they have been
subjected to dehumanising treatments despite their contribution to the
socio-economic growth of the state.
According to Ajie: “During the Col. Dominic Oneya administration,
that government entered into an agreement with traders at the market in a
25-year lease allowing traders to erect stalls round the perimeter
fence of the market in order to fortify security around the market.
“And since government is a continuum every administration in the
state respected that agreement until few days ago when the government
rolled out its bulldozers to pull down our stalls without notice and
destroying our goods valued at over N150million.
“We are surprised that after collecting huge sums of money from
traders as rent, the government failed to address the collapsing
infrastructure in the market but rather resorted to this unfortunate
action, it is indeed condemnable”.
In his comments, the Public Relations Officer of the traders, Mr.
Emeka Ofoagbu recalled the disagreements the traders had with the state
government last year over tenement rates.
He explained that the matter culminated in a legal battle and harassment of the traders by government agents.
Ofoegbu stressed, however, that the issue was eventually settled of
court with assurances from the government that facilities in the market
would be upgraded with proceeds from the new rates the state government
introduced in the market.
“But after making us pay the new rates, nothing was done to address the dilapidated infrastructures in the market.
“We had expected that on assumption of office, the new Commissioner
for Commerce and Industries would call traders in the market to a round
table discussion on critical issues affecting the market.
“But we were surprised that he rather chose to embark on the
demolition of stalls that were legally built by the traders themselves
without recourse to any form of dialogue,” he complained.
Ofoegbu emphasized that traders had expected that government would
embark on the rebuilding of the burnt section of the market which has
been abandoned for close to a decade rather than demolishing erected
structures.
Commenting, the Chairman of the Indigenous Traders Association in the
state, Mr. Paul Nyarkie lamented that the action of the state
government was a devastating blow to traders whose sources of livelihood
have been taken away.
Brandishing several documents indicating government’s requisite
approvals permitting the traders to construct the demolished stalls,
Nyarkie observed that the government’s action was an utter display of
recklessness.
“If this is the reward we deserve for supporting the government and
contributing to the socio-economic development of Benue State, it is too
bad; God is watching,” he said in an emotion-laden tone.
In his reaction however, the Commissioner for Commerce, Industry and
Tourism, Mr. Aler Adum who claimed he ordered the demolition of the
stalls informed that he would soon embark on the second phase of the
demolition exercise.
Relying on the edict governing the establishment and management of
the market, the Commissioner argued that he was statutorily empowered by
necessary laws to demolish “illegal structures”.
He contended that though the Dominic Oneya administration authorized
the construction of the stalls, the erected structures were not in the
original plan of the complex.
Adum described the claims of the traders that they were not properly
informed before the commencement of the demolition exercise as baseless.
According to him: “They were all served quit notices before we
commenced our action; their claim is baseless.They claimed that the Col.
Oneya administration entered into a 25-year lease with them, but the
truth is that under the military a lot of things were done wrongly and
it is glaring that law and order has gone on vacation in that market and
we are determined to make things works again at that facility.
“There is no way you can right a wrong without infringing on people’s
rights; as far as I am concerned what they think is their right is an
illegality,” Adum said.
He also intimated that the state government had concluded plans to
commence the rehabilitation of the multi million Naira market adding
that this would not come to fruition without restoring the original
master plan of the market.
Adum also debunked insinuations that the demolition exercise was
guided by political considerations, saying, “how can that be, when you
do not have inscriptions on the faces of the traders depicting the
political party they belong; those making such insinuations are ill
informed”.
The Commissioner who lament the poor rates currently being paid by
the traders, said, “Government sends huge sums of money to sustain the
market yet very little is generate from revenues”.
He disclosed of the decision of government to establish a limited
liability company to run the market and also charge occupants of stalls
appropriate rates as obtainable in markets across the country.
“All we are doing is in line with the power vested on me by law and
it is aimed at restoring sanity in the market; but if they decide to
challenge our action in court, we will definitely meet them there”, Adum
said
source vanguard.